http://www.linuxdevices.com/articles/AT9202043619.html
경험적 요약.
DirectFB : 우수하지만 되는 것이 별로 없음.
QT : 노키아가 먹었고 돈을 조금 내야 하는 듯.
GTK+ : 공짜이나 임베디드에서 무거움
DirectFB + GTK+ : 무겁고 호환성에 문제 있고 잠재적 버그.
Firefox on DirectFB + GTK+ : 빌드도 어렵고 파폭 버전도 구버전임. 문제점 다수
Webkit on DirectFB + GTK+ X-Window : 생각보다는 괜찮은 성능이나 무겁고 잠재 결함 예상
Tiny X : X-Window가 구버전임.
현재는 DirectFB 기반 하에 작업하고 있다. GTK+를 통째로 제거하고.. 다른 짓을...
링크가 사라져서 예전에 스크랩 한 내용을 옮겨놓음.
When you install Linux on a desktop PC, you normally choose from among a few "standard" graphics support components. You'll likely use the X Window system (XFree86 or ) as the display interface foundation (with associated Linux drivers to control the hardware), GNOME or KDE as a windowing environment, and one of several full-featured browsers such as Firefox, Konqueror, or Opera.
But the typical desktop Linux "graphics stack" isn't well suited to embedded Linux applications. Embedded devices frequently have highly constrained resources and can afford neither the program storage space nor the memory footprint of desktop graphics software. For example, embedded devices may easily have as little as 2 to 16 MB of Flash disk from which to load programs, and 4 to 32 MB of RAM memory in which to run them. But the typical desktop graphics components are notorious resource hogs . . . X Window System: 5MB RAM, 16MB disk GNOME: 14MB RAM, 95MB disk KDE: 11MB RAM, 96MB disk Mozilla: 12MB RAM, 26MB disk All that memory costs money, requires board space, and consumes power. Then too, embedded systems frequently have unique needs that can't be met by desktop graphics system components. These include the requirement for a customized look and feel, control over what functions are available to users, speed of loading, unusual display or input device characteristics, etc.
To satisfy the demands of the rapidly emerging embedded Linux marketplace, a growing number of graphics support projects and products have sprung up. Targeted environments run the full gamut -- including fixed, portable, and mobile systems -- and the applications range from hand-held consumer products like PDAs and cell phones, to medical instruments, factory automation, and commercial airlines cockpit displays.
With this in mind, LinuxDevices.com has created The Embedded Linux Graphics Quick Reference Guide. We intend to continually update this guide -- so be sure to check back frequently for the latest info.
Open source Embedded Linux Graphics System Software Dillo -- Dillo is a very small (less than 300KB), fast, Open Source multi-platform web browser that's written completely in C and built on GTK+ libraries. Dillo's high efficiency and minimal library dependencies make it quite suitable for embedded apps. Dillo can be teamed up with an embedded webserver to completely eliminate the need for a window manager in an embedded device. -- details
DirectFB -- DirectFB is a thin library that provides developers with hardware graphics acceleration, input device handling and abstraction, integrated windowing system with support for translucent windows and multiple display layers on top of the Linux Framebuffer Device. It is a complete hardware abstraction layer with software fallbacks for every graphics operation that is not supported by the underlying hardware. -- details
The Familiar Project -- this open source PDA Linux project, which is an offshoot of the activities at handhelds.org, has collected together all of the key components of a complete Linux-based PDA computing platform. The Familiar distribution currently includes a Blackbox-based window manager, Agenda Computing's Fltk+ based PIM applications, an embedded Python implementation, system configuration and settings backup utilities, OpenSSH client and server, and a Debian-based ARM kernel. -- details
FBUI -- FBUI is a tiny GUI that resides inside the Linux kernel. The key concepts of FBUI are that firstly it is small; secondly that it is spartan, which is good; thirdly that it is just another driver; and fourthly that drivers belong in the kernel, not in userspace. details
GGI project -- the "General Graphics Interface" project is dedicated to development of fast, stable, open-source cross-platform multimedia API systems. Designed from the ground up with environments such as embedded systems in mind, GGI is fast, clean, abstract, dynamically modular and highly optimizeable. -- details
GPE Palmtop Environment -- this project aims to provide a Free Software GUI environment for palmtop/handheld computers running the GNU/Linux operating system. GPE uses the X Window System, and the GTK+ widget toolkit. -- details
GtkFB -- beginning with version 2.0, GTK+ will support rendering directly to the Linux framebuffer instead of using the X Window System. This is good for embedded systems and devices with limited resources, because it eliminates the overhead of an X server, while still taking advantage of the power of GTK+ and the large base of existing programs. -- details
handhelds.org PDA support -- want to create your own unique Linux PDA implementation? handhelds.org is for you! Early this year, Compaq created the Open Handheld Program, an initiative designed to stimulate innovation and research on handheld devices that resulted from the company's "Itsy" pocket computer project. To support this initiative, Compaq created handhelds.org -- a vendor neutral website dedicated to open source handheld development. Not surprisingly, Compaq's iPAQ PDA is used as the base platform for all these activities and, consequently, a iPAQ Linux port is available as freely available open source software. -- details
Matchbox -- a small foot-print window manager and associated applications, designed specifically for resource-constrained X11-enabled devices such as handheld computers, PDA's, set-top boxes, and consumer devices where display size, storage, CPU bandwidth, and input mechanisms are limited. Matchbox includes a window manager, a panel, a desktop, a shared utility library, and a number of small panel applications. -- details
Microwindows -- an Open Source project aimed at bringing the features of modern graphical windowing environments to smaller devices and platforms. Microwindows applications can be built and tested on the Linux desktop, as well as cross-compiled for the target device. -- details
NxZilla (formerly nanozilla) -- a set of libraries that allow Mozilla to be used with a NanoX server from the Microwindows project. -- details
OpenGL ES -- a light-weight, royalty-free embedded graphics standard that provides graphics API profiles for a broad range of embedded systems and devices, including handheld wireless devices, automotive and avionics displays, and multimedia consumer devices such as advanced digital TVs, set-top boxes, and game consoles. -- details
OpenGUI -- a fast, 32-bit, high-Level C/C++ graphics & windowing library/GUI built upon a fast, low-level x86 asm graphics kernel. It is under LGPL license. OpenGUI provides 2D drawing primitives and an event-driven windowing API for easy application development. -- details
PicoGUI -- small, portable client/server GUI designed to work on many types of hardware including handheld computers. Like the X Window System, it has a flexible client-server architecture. Unlike X, however, fonts, bitmaps, widgets, and anything else the application needs are built directly into the server. This sacrifices a small decrease in flexibility for an increase in speed and a large decrease in size. -- details
Qt/Embedded -- provides a full graphics stack, from the hardware interface to a full GUI tookkit. Although the API is identical to the popular Qt/X11 and Qt/Windows products, Qt/Embedded is not based on X11 and therefore it has substantially reduced memory requirements. Memory demands can be tuned to the range of 800 KB to 3 MB in ROM (Intel x86). Qt/Embedded is available as open source software, under the GNU General Public License (GPL), or can be licensed on other terms from its originator, Trolltech. -- details
Simple DirectMedia Layer -- an open source cross-platform multimedia development API/library designed to provide fast access to the graphics framebuffer and audio device. SDL is currently being applied to a number of Embedded Linux implementations such as Microwindows. details
Tiny-X -- a small footprint X Window server implementation for embedded systems. It was developed by Keith Packard of the XFree86 Core Team, sponsored by SuSE. The goal was to create something that would work well in a small memory footprint and, importantly, be robust in near out-of-memory situations. Typical X servers based on Tiny-X can fit in less than 1MB on x86 CPUs. The project has since forked into several projects, including KDrive, SmallX, and Integrated Tiny-X.
ViewML -- a freely available, open source web browser targeted specifically at the embedded Linux platform. Currently, ViewML along with it's interface requires 2.1 MB of RAM, with a disk image of only 760K. -- details
WML Browser -- a project, sponsored by 5NINE to develop a browser which will allow any wireless device to have WAP functionality. It must support multiple protocol stacks (WAP 1.2.1, http), in differing environments, using differing input devices. The browser will work with framebuffer graphics. -- details
Xynth Windowing System -- a free software project to build a portable, embedded client-server windowing system. The Xynth Windowing System, released under the GPL, offers a lightweight GUI-capable windowing system usable in Linux-based embedded systems and devices, such as handhelds and set-top boxes. details
"Commercial" Embedded Linux Graphics System Software
Access: Netfront browser -- an embedded browser designed for information appliances with modest memory and CPU performance. It requires less than 1.3MB ROM and 2MB RAM, supports full HTML 3.2 and selected features from HTML 4.0, frames, JavaScript, cookies, Web-printing and multi-languages. Its modular and scalable architecture can be enhanced by application-specific modules and plug-ins. An independent user interface layer and design tool allows device manufacturers to create a unique look and feel for their product. -- details
ANT: Freesco browser -- a small memory footprint, standards-compliant JAVA based browser that enables OEMs to quickly and easily design a branded interface for Internet appliances. It is platform-independent, so it can be used with any hardware or operating system environment (including various implementations of Embedded Linux). -- details
Century Software: PIXIL PDA and Microwindows -- a complete PDA system including an operating environment, PIM applications, email client, web browser, and a set of multimedia applications. The Microwindows graphical windowing system (described above) is at the core of the PIXIL PDA solution. -- details
Espial: Espial Suite -- a complete, 100% Java application layer that sits independently from the operating system and JVM on the upper layer of a device stack and has been used extensively with Linux. Espial Suites include the following applications: Espial DeviceTop graphical OSGi client, Espial Escape web browser, Espial Ebox email client, and Espial Espresso lightweight GUI toolkit.
Feynman Software: MiniGUI -- [Oct. 26, 2005] -- a dual-licensed (GPL or commercially licensable) project to create a small windowing system support library for embedded systems and devices, which offers the equivalent window management functions of Win32 APIs. -- Details here (article), here (link), and here (news).
Fluffy Spider: FancyPants -- [Oct. 26, 2005] -- This commercial graphics framework from Australian ISV Fluffy Spider is a set of lightweight special effects software for user interfaces (UIs). FancyPants supports skinning, overlays, and fancy effects, and targets media-centric consumer and mobile devices, such as POS (point-of-sales/service) systems, set-top boxes, and mobile phones. Details here, here, and here.
NetClue: Clue WBC browser -- a compact, modular, and platform independent 100% Java browser. Clue WBC supports Unicode for international characters, smooth scrolling, streamline parsing and display, web printing, customizable user-interface, and is WAP compliant. Other features include support for HTML 4.0, XML, HTTP 1.0 and 1.1, CSS, DOM, cookies, JavaScript, Java Applets. -- details
Swell Software: LinuxPEG -- LinuxPEG is an embedded GUI library and development toolkit designed specifically for embedded systems. The LinuxPEG library is designed to run on any Linux distribution and its development tools run in the X11 development environment. LinuxPEG, which is available under license, is small footprint, completely ROMable, includes full C++ source code, and is royalty fee. -- details
Trolltech: Qtopia and Qt/Embedded -- Qtopia is a mobile device window environment and application suite for PDAs, palmtop computers, Internet appliances, and similar devices. Qtopia is based on Qt/Embedded (described above), and includes PIM applications, Internet clients, entertainment and games, utilities, and more. Qtopia/PDA is available in commercial or open source licenses, while Qtopia Phone Edition is commercial-only. -- details